Investigating Preference Index-based Palatability of Rangeland Plants in Sirik Region, Hormozgan Province

Authors

‎10.22052/deej.2021.11.34.29

Abstract

Introduction: Measuring the preferred value of rangeland plants is one of the most important factors in determining rangelands' grazing capacity. The preferential value of rangeland plants is measured based on the type of livestock which uses the rangeland and the changes made in the rangeland during the grazing season. This study sought to investigate the palatability of rangeland plant species within the Sirik rangeland (Hormozgan province) during the grazing season (January to May) of the years 2007-2010.

Materials and Methods: The study area was located at sand dunes of Sirik city (Hormozgan province) at 26˚ 39ʹ 12ʺ and 57˚ 4ʹ 26ʺ overlooking the sea. The 30-year ambrothermic curve of the study area showed that the wet and dry seasons lasted one and eleven months, respectively. The average minimum and maximum temperatures of the study area in the coldest and warmest months of the year were found to be 14.36 °C and 33.78 °C, respectively. However, the lowest and highest temperatures in the region were 5.5 and 48.5 °C, respectively, and its average 30-year rainfall rate was 121.8 mm.
The region's rangeland type was a mixture of Sphaerocoma aucheri and Cenchrus pennisetoformis. In the study area, seventy plant species from twenty-eight genera were collected and identified, the most important of which were Moltkiopsis Ciliata, Heliotropium bacciferum, Cyperus conglomeratus, and Panicum turgidum. The livestock examined in this study was Tali goat that is bred in Hormozgan, Sistan and Baluchestan, and Bushehr provinces.

This study was conducted in Sirik rangeland, Hormozgan province, throughout the grazing season (January to May) for four consecutive years (2007 to 2010). The study area comprised a one-hectare enclosed area located on sand dunes ten kilometers away from Sirik city, overlooking the sea. At the beginning of the grazing season, five similar rootstocks were selected for each species and marked inside and outside the enclosed area.
The forage of each rootstock was placed in a separate bag and weighed. Then the consumption percentage was determined for each species. Each species' share in the livestock diet was determined throughout the grazing season by calculating the percentage of production and consumption of species inside and outside the enclosed area. Moreover, the preference index was obtained by dividing the species' share outside the enclosed area by its share inside the area. Finally, preferential value indices were determined according to the classification proposed by Rosiere et al. (1975). The study's results were analyzed in a time-based split-plot statistical design through a complete randomized block design in SAS software, followed by comparing the statistical mean of the studied features with the results of the LSD test.

Results: The analysis of the variance of the preferred index showed that there was no significant difference among the studied years. However, a significant difference was found between the months of the study period and between the species examined. The years of the study period were grouped together in one statistical category, and the months of the study period were classified into two statistical categories. The highest value of the preference index was found in March, which was in the same group as January. Cenchrus pennisetoformis showed the highest preference index with the value of 1.516, followed by Cyperus conglumeratus, whose value was reported to be 1.338, both of which were not statistically significant. It was also found that Cenchrus pennisetoformis was a relatively palatable species (relative preference), Cyperus conglumeratus, Sphaerocoma aucheri, Moltkiopsis Ciliata, and Panicum turgidum were moderately palatable species (moderate preference), and Heliotropium bacciferum was identified as almost a non-palatable (relative avoidance) species.

Discussion and Conclusion: Cenchrus pennisetoformis was identified as the highest livestock preference in Sirik rangeland, Hormozgan province. According to the classification table proposed by Rosiere et al. (1975), the species is classified as palatable with a preference index of 1.516. Moreover, Cenchrus pennisetoformis was one of the region's low-density and highly consumed species. The second livestock preference in Sirik rangeland was Cyperus conglumeratus, whose preference index was found to be 1.338, representing a boundary between the ratio of good food and average good food. The two species were then grouped together in a statistical category. The third preference rank belonged to Sphaerocoma aucheri with a value of 0.960, which was a highly distributed and consumed species in the region with the highest dense value. It should be noted that this species plays an essential role in Tali goat's nutrition at the end of the grazing season, i.e., April and May, when the annuals are dried up.
Other preference indices belonged to Moltkiopsis ciliate and Panicum turgidum, with index values of 0.819 and 0.800, respectively, both of which are classified as moderately palatable species. Moreover, annuals with a preference index of 0.729, including Stipa capensis, Plantago psylium, Erucaria hispanica, Mathiola longipetala, Fagonia bruguieri, Anagalis arvensis, and Medicago polymorpha were among the moderately palatable species. However, it should be noted that at the beginning of the grazing season, the livestock tends to graze those plants that are more than one year old, while at the end of the grazing season, when the grasses are dried up or sowed, the one-year-old plants are less favored by the livestock. Finally, the last preference index belonged to Heliotropium bacciferum with an index of 0.605, which was classified as an almost non-edible species.

Keywords


  1. Ahmadi, A., 2009. Determination of preference value and grazing behavior of range plants for different ages of sheep in deserts and steppes Qom. PhD thesis, Islamic Azad University, Science and Research Branch, Tehran, Iran, 187 p.
  2. Ameri, H. and Mesdaghi, M., 2002. Study of nutritional selection of indigenous plants in semi-steppe rangelands of northern Semnan. Iranian Journal of Range and Desert Research, 8: 849-857.
  3. Baghestani Meybodi, N., An investigation on the effects of short term grazing intensity of goats on different plant characteristics and animal function in steppe rangeland of Yazd, Ph.D. Thesis. University of Tehran, 214 p.
  4. Baghestani Meybodi, N. and Arzani, H., 2006. An Investigation of Range Plants, Palatability and Goat Behaviour in Posht-Kooh Rangelands, Yazd province. Iranian Journal of Natural Resources, 58 (4): 109-119.
  5. Dianati Tilaki, Gh. and Mir Jalili, A., 2007. Investigation on Palatability of Rangeland Plants in Yazd region. Journal of Pajouhesh & Sazandegi, 76: 69-73.
  6. Fayaz, M., Yeganeh, H., Afrah, H., Aliakbarzadeh Alni, E., Noori, A. V. and Bayat, M. 2018. Determining forage species preference value for Moghani sheep using species selection index in Yaypaq rangeland of Ardabil Province. Rangelands, 12 (1): 14-23.
  7. Fayaz, M. and Bayat, M. 2016. Perference value of range plants of Iran (Steppe and desert pastures of Iran). Forest and Rangeland Research Institute, no. 473.
  8. Fayaz, M. and Yeganeh, H., 2015. Perference value of range plants of Iran (Rangelands of semi-steppe and high mountains of Iran). Forest and Rangeland Research Institute, no. 456.
  9. Fayaz, M., Ameri, H., Yazdanshenas, H. and Yeganeh, H., 2015. Study of preference value of range plants for camel in winter and summer pastures of Semnan province during three consecutive years. Journal of Plant Research (Iranian Journal of Biology), 28 (4): 794-802.
  10. Hasani, J. and Fayaz, M., 2014. Investigation on preference value of range species and grazing behavior in Qorveh Rangelands of Kurdistan. Iranian Journal of Range and Desert Reseach, 21 (2): 357-367.
  11. Hosseini, S.A. and Fayaz, M., 2014. An investigation of preference value of important range plants in Saraliabad Gorgan Rangelands in different phenological stages. Iranian Journal of Range and Desert Research, 21 (3): 424-434.
  12. Khosravi, A. and Sharafatmand, M., 2020. Determining the preference value of plant species for Baluchi sheep and red Jabalbarez goat using filming method in winter rangelands. Desert Ecosystem Engineering Journal, 9 (26): 1-14.
  13. Mirdavoodi, H.R. and Sanadgol, A.A., 2009. Study of preference value of range plants in key ranges of Anjedan's rangelands of Markazi province. Iranian Journal of Range and Desert Research, 16 (2): 190-199.
  14. Najafi, K. and Fayaz, M., 2011. Final report of investigation on preference value of range species and grazing behavior in Javengan Geno Rangelands of Hormozgan province. Hormozgan Research Center for Agriculture and Natural Resource, Bandarabbas, Iran, 71 p.
  15. Najibzadeh, M. R., Bayat, M., Pezeshki, M. H. and Fayaz, M. 2018. Investigation the preference value of the most important species inSahand rangelands of East Azarbaijan province. 7th National Conference on Rangeland and Rangeland Management of Iran.
  16. Naseri, Gh., Abarsaji, A. and Fayaz, M., 2015. Study of preference value of range plants in Til Abad region, Golestan province. Iranian Journal of Range and Desert Research, 22 (2): 373-381.
  17. Papachriston, T. G., Dziba, L. E. and Provenza, F. D., 2005. Botanical composition determination of range herbivore diets: a review. Journal of Small Ruminant Research, 59: 141-156.
  18. Rashtian, A., Mesdaghi, M., Boldaji, F. and Barani, H., 2010. Determination of preference value of seven important range species in steppe region of Yazd province (Case study: Nodoshan rangelands). Journal of Agricultural Sciences and Natural Resources, 16 (3): 215-232.
  19. Rogosic, J., Pfister, J., Provenza, F. and Grbesa, D., 2006. Sheep and goat preference for and nutritional value of Mediterranean maquis shrubs. Small Ruminant Research, 64: 169–179.
  20. Rosiere, R.E., Beck, R. F. and Wallace, J. D., 1975. Cattle diets on semi desert grassland: botanical composition. Journal of Range Management, 28 (2): 89-93.
  21. Saghafi, F., Fayaz, M. and Naseri, S., 2013. Determination of preference value and its variation during the grazing season for different species in Binalood rangelands, Khorasan. Iranian Journal of Range and Desert Research, 22 (2): 369-378.
  22. Soltanipoor, M. A. and Fayaz, M., 2010. Final report of investigation on preference value of range species and grazing behavior in Zaminsang Rangelands of Hormozgan province. Hormozgan Research Center for Agriculture and Natural Resource, Bandarabbas, Iran, 71 p.
  23. Zare, M., Fayaz, M., Goudarzi, Gh. and Farmahini farahani, A., 2012. Preference value comparison in range species Anjedan-Arak. Iranian journal of Range and Desert Reseach, 19 (1): 178-190.